Skip to content

Best and Worst UX in the Travel Industry

 By Userlytics
 Dec 12, 2019
 27918 views

Best and Worst UX in the Travel Industry

The Best and Worst UX in the Travel Industry

The Best and Worst UX in the Travel Industry

Finding the best flight deals online can be an exhilarating experience. Almost every booking site today promises the lowest fares available and, in some cases, even a price match guarantee. With such a wide range of flying options and airlines stepping up their online game, we decided to take a look at the top players providing the best travel booking options – along with some travel sites which are clearly lagging behind.

To understand the current travel landscape, Userlytics invited a group of 10 US-based consumers age 18 to 65 who had searched and booked a flight online in the past 60 days, to share some of their thoughts based on their recent booking experience. The study asked participants to complete a series of guided tasks simulating searching and getting detailed flight information on their preferred and least preferred travel engines.

Taking advantage of Userlytics features such as Picture in Picture view, we were able to follow each of the participants approach and reactions to the required tasks.

Participants’ experience at various stages of the study. In combination with the on-screen recordings, we got a glimpse to the time spent on specific tasks based on the metrics provided by Userlytics. Making it easier to compare the results between the top and worst travel platforms. For the test, the first open ended question: “Think back to a travel website that you have you have used in the past to book flights that provided an excellent experience…” yielded two main contenders: Expedia and Orbitz. Both sites have been around for quite some time and have become a go-to destination not only for flights but for complete travel bundles (hotels, cars, cruises).

Ranking of most popular travel sites based on testers’ preferences

Based on their response, testers were tasked with navigating to their preferred travel site (and their least favorite one) and finding a flight with a specific scenario in mind.

Here are some of the key insights from this exercise.

Straightforward and smart from the start

The most popular sites like Expedia and Google Flights offered users a preview of the price results, even as they were inputting search parameters. Expedia and Google Flights displayed tentative prices on a collapsible calendar for each date as they were selected on the home page.

Tester highlighting the fare prediction functionality on Google Flights. Another feature welcomed by some testers was the option to filter their flight options by setting a price limit on the results page.

Currently, most sites allow for sorting results from ‘lowest to highest’ but only Google Flights uses a sliding scale to filter out the options that fall outside a traveler’s budget.

Bargains with strings attached

For this staging, users were given a limited budget to find a flight to Paris during one of the busiest months of the year: December.

For this specific parameter, travel engines like Priceline presented some of the most ‘budget-friendly’ options in the industry. A special offer called Express Deals or Mystery Flight turned out to be a good match for this purpose. But it came with a catch…flight details are not made available until the reservation is completed. This means, that there is no information about the airline operating the route (although possible airlines are listed with their logos), no estimate on the flight duration or expected layovers. Additional fees are also kept undisclosed until the end. While a good budget option in theory for the more adventurous travelers, these Express Deals didn’t offer the complete and detailed information our testers needed in order to choose their flight.

Details matter

If getting clear information about the total flight cost proved to be time consuming, understanding baggage fees definitely brought frustration to a majority of the participants.

None of the sites visited currently offer the option of filtering by baggage allowance or additional charges. Across the board, the information about baggage cost was difficult to locate even when going into the specific details of each flight. Orbitz is the only site to offer an easy way to locate this information under the Details and Baggage Fees expandable section listed in each one of the flight results regardless of the airline carrier.

Orbtiz’s preview of baggage fees when booking. Following a similar format and language, Expedia and Google Flights also offer baggage information but it takes testers at least two or more steps to successfully locate this.

Miles away…

One of the biggest pain points for most of our users came from the sites that by default selected flight+hotels bundles, instead of flight only options. This automatic setting was a source of confusion especially on Travelocity where the current layout makes it difficult for users to pick their preferred flight option without choosing a hotel. Another overly complex experience came from CheapOair. Participants complained about the fact that as an aggregator site, there is “too much going on”.

Flight results seem to be jumbled and, in some cases, inconsistent with search parameters. The language used was also a source of confusion and, provided limited useful information to travelers.

Tester sharing his thoughts about the experience on CheapOair. Unfortunately for CheapOair, the high-pressure selling technique which shows the number of people looking at the same flight option was not well received.

Positioning the site as one of the least favorite options for travelers.

The verdict

Based on the input received from the users, the leading flight booking option at the moment is Orbitz closely followed by Google Flights. Expedia felt behind due to loading time for some participants.

Overall, these three sites provide a consistent experience and offer the necessary information in order to successfully look for a flight, compare prices and understand potential additional baggage fees. There has been a standardization for the filtering options present across sites, allowing participants to sort by price, flight duration, number of stops. However, none of the booking platforms feature a bag allowance filter – forcing users to go into each flight result to locate and carefully read over estimated extra fees. Not surprisingly, the poorest ranked booking platforms (CheapOair, JustFly, AsapTickets, Travelocity) were the ones presenting participants with immense amount of information in a poorly structured form.

Additionally, flight prices found on these sites appeared to be significantly cheaper from the ones across the industry – making users wary of the authenticity of the results. These platforms also received low ratings on the usability aspect, based on the feedback from testers. To determine this, participants were asked to share their experience through The System Usability Scale (SUS). The SUS allows to quickly understand the usability of a site in comparison to industry standards; it consists of 10 statements (positive and negative) presented to users to which they need to agree or disagree. This helps calculate the score for a site’s usability. If a site scores above 68 it’s considered “above average” and it means that it suffers little to none usability issues. On the contrary, a site scoring under 68 means it’s “below average” and presents moderate to significant usability issues. For our test, the group of sites scoring “above average” featured Expedia, Orbitz, Google Flight and received a collective average score of 89. In the case of websites like CheapOair, JustFly, Asap Tickets their collective SUS ranking came at 53.25 – indicating important usability matters with these platforms.

SUS average score for the less popular travel sites In combination with the conducted tasks from testers on the different travel sites, the SUS ratings provide key indicators of the overall user experience for these websites. Running this specific test on Userlytics provided the convenience of having access to a diverse set of qualified users, as well as the opportunity to obtain a set of insights (quantitative and qualitative) which can serve to inform better usability decisions. Having the opportunity to understand potential users’ preferences when it comes to searching and booking for travel online is key to improving their future on-site experience. While most sites today offer similar functionalities (flexible dates, price comparison, results sorting), the easiness by which they make these options available to users is crucial to building a loyal customer base.

Didn’t find what you were searching for?

Related posts

Things to be Thankful for: Advantages of Professional Peer Support in UX Research Thanksgiving is a time to reflect on all the things we are thankful for. As user researchers, we are thankful for the ability to connect with our peers and
2022 has been a busy and exciting time at Userlytics. We’ve launched several new features and capabilities, including sentiment analysis, accessibility testing, the ULX score, and VR testing. These newly implemented tools were designed to enhance your experience and provide you with
As staples of nearly all research conducted today, many people think they know about the differences between qualitative (qual) and quantitative (quant) testing. However, in the context of user research, these two methodologies are often used interchangeably. So how does one know
Understanding what democratizing user research means is not as simple as searching for the definition online, or asking a colleague for a quick summary. In a general sense, the universal definition is “providing all stakeholders with access to user insight and UX
It's no secret that a good website or app user experience is crucial for boosting sales. In an offline location such as a store or restaurant, being physically present may keep a prospect even if the experience is subpar. But in an
For many researchers working in UX, quantitative data analysis can cause a lot of anxiety. UX researchers provide interpretations that can impact businesses with said data, which can be an overwhelming amount of pressure. There are many reasons UX researchers are often
As a UX researcher or designer, it's important to have a clear understanding of your target customer before beginning a remote UX study. This helps you make informed decisions about what to test, how to test it, and who to target your
If you’re a UX researcher, you probably already know how important it is to carefully consider every step of a research plan: You need to make sure you understand the problem space, choose the most suitable research methods, identify and recruit the
In remote user experience and usability testing, there are a variety of factors that contribute to valuable, authentic user data that can be used to improve your brand’s user and customer experience. Among those factors are the quality and authenticity of the
Are you thinking about doing some user testing on your website, app or prototype? Are you currently weighing up the different options available to you? Should you use a free video-conferencing tool or a paid user testing platform? What are the differences
If you visited a complex website and found everything you were looking for with ease, it was unlikely a coincidence. A well-designed website structure is often the result of careful user research and testing, following information architecture principles and best practices. So
While remote user experience testing significantly enhances researchers' ability to reach test participants, these participants’ technical skills and access to technology can often vary greatly. Therefore, it is important to design and administer remote tests that facilitate participants' varying technical skills and
Userlytics prides itself in being a truly global platform. With over one million panel testers in over 150 countries, we are happy to say that we are able to find and test your target customers, wherever they may be. With the inception
In today’s highly digital world, cybersecurity is of the utmost importance when running day to day business operations. As usability testing grows in popularity, so does the need to choose a UX platform that values your company's privacy and security. But how
Userlytics makes user experience testing easy, efficient and fun with its state-of-the-art no-download web recorder. This revolutionary user experience testing recorder allows participants to jump right into usability tests directly with a simple click of a button; this means you can more
Moderated testing is a great opportunity to get thorough and instant feedback from users all around the world. This type of testing involves a live, online interview where you are face-to-face with your users via webcam, asking them questions, guiding them through
Researching the ins and outs of your business is integral to setting your company up for success. Increasingly, fine-tuning and improving your customers’ brand experience has become one of the top priorities for businesses. With customer expectations being at an all-time high,
Are you a UX researcher who mainly conducts in-person studies and you’re looking for some online alternatives to get you through this unusual period of lockdown and social distancing? Or perhaps you’re someone who is starting their path down UX enlightenment, looking
INTRODUCTION Given the current world health and associated economic crisis, Userlytics ran a qualitative moderated ("Live Conversations") user experience study with participants in the US to determine how respondents’ online shopping behavior has changed as a result of the pandemic. The following
Imagine a scenario where a user is shopping online and stumbles across a product she likes, but the product’s description doesn’t tell her everything she needs to know before making a purchase (strike 1). To find out more, the user decides to
Last November 18th our CEO was interviewed by Ditsa Keren, of Website Planet; Here are some excerpts from the interview: “If we take a step back and think about how software has evolved over the past 15 years, the cost and time
Designers are prone to falling into the trap of cluttering their interfaces. Limitations of space often push them to the wall, and they find themselves trying to fit everything they can into a tiny usable space. The unique problem that the modern
How Can Bad UX Influence Your Conversion Funnel? Source: Shengjun Shi Regardless of whether you sell a product, offer a service or run a blog, any visitor comes to your site with simple goals like consuming or gathering more information. The user experience

Let’s work together on your next UX study.

Create positive user experiences and keep customers loyal to your product and brand.

Analytics tells you what,
Userlytics tells you WHY.